Pegasus Coffee House

Reviews

• Steph G.

  star star star star star 23 June 2026

  Very cute and unique coffee shop on the island. It's about a 5 minute stroll from the main part of downtown Bainbridge and located closer to the marina. They have a very good location for those needing a quick refreshment after window shopping.
  
  Plenty of shaded outdoor seating, lots of tables inside. Their menu is awesome. They have lots of local wines, iced tea, cider, coffee, you name it. I have never had food here but the dishes look great. They're currently promoting a kimchi grilled cheese. Sounds interesting. The kind of intriguing interesting that I'm all about! Sadly, I didn't get food this trip.
  
  Lots of cool locals and tourists hanging around chatting. I love this place and it's always a must for when I'm on the island!

• Rana M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 20 June 2026

  I'm sorry the matcha tasted awful, the chai tasted like cinnamon only with loads of sugar & the mocha was so sweet... I don't like writing bad reviews but they ruined my experience at the island.
  
  The barista though was so nice & friendly.

• Alecia P.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  You must grab a drink when you're in Bainbridge! My best friend & I decided to do a day trip to Bainbridge just for their coffee since it's the OG Pegasus cafe. We came on a Saturday thinking it would be busy, but surprisingly it wasn't at all. We ended up ordering a London Fog & an Ice Hazelnut Mocha. London was seeped just right! The espresso in the Iced Mocha was bomb, the sweetness wasn't overpowering at all.
  
  It was so aesthetically pleasing from inside and out! There was plenty of seating to choose from. They even have outdoor seating for warmer days!
  
  Parking was super easy for us, we got street parking right in front of the cafe. But honestly, parking on Bainbridge wasn't a problem at all. Everything is within walking distance, so wherever you parked you'll be fine!
  
  The ivy covered building & cute decor inside was on point. We took our time just chatting away! But overall a very vibe. It's a great place to have a drink with a friend and catch up or even study!

• Isabel S.

  star star star star star_border 8 June 2026

  A little slow but I have a feeling this town runs slower than the busy city across the ferry ride. There was only one girl working the register and making the drinks at the same time so when our group of six ordered she kind of had a backlog of drinks. A guy who I assume was the owner came from the back and helped her out so our stuff was out sooner than expected. I got a latte which was delicious and perfectly made and a cinnamon roll. You can taste the cinnamon roll quality ingredients like butter and a light sugary topping with a dense dough and lots of cinnamon. The price was pretty good for a 16oz cup and the cinnamon roll about $8.
  The view of the marina and the boats outside is so pretty and very picturesque to enjoy with your cup of joe.

• Christian L.

  star star star star star 4 June 2026

  If you like a local good coffee, this is the place. Their beans are locally roasted and produce a creamy espresso, bitter but not acid and with a short taste.
  A must visit.